Overblog
Editer l'article Suivre ce blog Administration + Créer mon blog
Affaire Seznec Investigation

Le blog de Liliane Langellier. Premier blog sur l'affaire Seznec. Plus de 880 articles.

Affaire Seznec : Robert D. Murphy serait-il Charly ?

Ce cher Marc du Ryez m'écrit : 
 
Bertrand Vilain a mis une photo de son Charly sur son blog. J'ai aussitôt comparé à des photos de Robert D. Murphy, dont je vous parlais dans un commentaire (les trois noms visibles sur la couverture étant Reilly, Hoover et Murphy).
Je cite ce passage de mon commentaire : "À moins que Charly, ce soit Hoover ? Ou Robert Daniel Murphy, vice-consul des États-Unis à Zurich en 1921 et à Munich en 1921-1925 ? On s'imagine mal Achermann, le très modeste charpentier, en rapport avec des personnages de ce niveau, cependant." Charpentier : je voulais dire menuisier (automobile), soit dit en passant. C'est son père qui était charpentier.
 
Zurich, donc, où Murphy pourrait avoir rencontré Achermann. L'Allemagne, où Achermann se rendait apparemment à l'occasion, même si son travail à l'usine ne lui laissait pratiquement aucun temps libre (pas de congés payés).
Dans son PV d'audition : "J'ai fait un voyage à Coblence au mois d'avril dernier vers le 17 ou 18. Je ne suis resté absent que trois jours." Mais il y a loin de Coblence à Munich (500 km).
 
Je vous joins la photo de Charly et trois photos de Murphy. La ressemblance est là (sourcils froncés, très grand nez, petit menton rond, double menton, chapeau sombre cachant la calvitie), même si on ne peut rien affirmer de définitif. 
 

in Le Wapo du 11 janvier 1978 :

Robert D. Murphy, 83, a shrewd adviser to Presidents and a skilled negotiator in areas of foreign policy and intelligence who was one of the major figures in American diplomacy for decades, died last night at his home in Manhattan.

From before the outbreak of World War II, Mr. Murphy's quickly recognized abilities won him an almost unparalleled opportunity to both watch history being made on a global scale and to take part in its making.

During a 40-year career in the foreign service that included two ambassadorships and culminated in his holding the top career post in the State Department -- Under Secretary of State, Mr. Murphy served with distinction and handled delicate missions in many of the world's most sensitive trouble spots.

He was a young foreign service officer in Germany during the rise of Hitler. He was in Paris in 1940 when France fell. He was in North Africa in 1942 when the British and American forces landed.

Indeed, in the difficult and confusing game of deception and intrigue that preceded the landings, it was Mr. Murphy who, with the support and confidence of President Roosevelt, skillfully played the American hand.

From 1942 until the end of World War II, he was on the staff of Gen. Dwight D. Eisenhower in Europe, helping negotiate the Italian armistice in 1943, and dealing with many other vital political matters surrounding the Allied war effort.

Afterward, he was political adviser to Gen. Lucius Clay, the military governor of the U.S. Zone of Germany when the Russians began the celebrated Berlin blockade in 1948.

As ambassador to Japan during part of the Korean War period, he helped to negotiate an end of the fighting.

In 1958, at the time of yet another crisis, he was sent by the Eisenhower administration to Lebanon to serve as a diplomatic troubleshooter.

A large-boned, stoop-shouldered man of 6 feet 4 inches, described by admirers as "affable, friendly, exceedingly shrewd," Mr. Murphy helped cool tensions at several other hotspots, and was named Career Ambassador before retiring from the Foreign Service in 1960.

After leaving full-time government service he became chairman of Corning Glass International, a post from which he stepped down about five years ago.

Even after retirement from the State Department, he continued to play a major role in government and foreign affairs as a member of the Foreign Intelligence Advisory Board.

A man whose connections with the world of intelligence could be traced back to his service in the U.S. Legation in Berne, Switzerland, from 1917, 1919, When spymaster Allen Dulles was attached there, Mr. Murphy supplied advice in that area of Presidents Kennedy, Johnson, Nixon and Ford.

Named by President Ford early in 1976 to serve as chairman of the new Board of Intelligence Oversight, Mr. Murphy has been credited with playing an important role in the recent reassessment of american intelligence policies and procedures.

In another of his advisory posts, the much-honored former ambassador also headed a 12-member Commission for Reorganization of the Government's Foreign Policy. The body was created in 1972 by President Nixon and Congress.

A man who combined a nononsense toughmindedness with his well-known geniality, Mr. Murphy was born and brought up in Milwaukee, and came to Washington as a young man.

After a year as a post office clerk, Mr. Murphy, a skilled shorthand reporter, who was disqualified from World War I service by a crushed foot, got a job as a consular clerk in the legation in Berne.

He later returned here and studied law at night at George Washington University. In 1920, after receiving his degree and winning admission to the bar, he declined a post in a law firm, and entered the consular service, attracted, he said, by the "lure of working abroad."

In 1936, while U.S. consul in Paris, he reached a major milestone on the road that led eventually to the top levels of American diplomacy.

Ambassador William Bullitt recognized his abilities, and had him transferred to the U.S. Embassy as first secretary.

When German troops entered Paris in 1940, Mr. Murphy met with the German commander to protect American and French interests.

In july and August, 1940, as charge d'affaires at Vichy, he reportedly assumed the role of secret agent, on instructions from Roosevelt, to open the cat-and-mouse negotiations that paved the way for the eventual North African landings.

Using an assumed name, he played a key role in the subtle, demanding bargaining with French Gen. Henri Giraud and Adm. Jean Darlan.

In November, 1942, he persuaded Darlan, of the Vichy government, to sign an armistice agreement. Although, criticized by some Americans as the "Darlan deal," the pact was supported by top U.S. officials and Mr. Murphy received the Distinguished Service Medal.

In several situations, as in North Africa, critics of Mr. Murphy's work sometimes complained that he showed an undue affinity for the more conservative elements in nations and governments with which he dealt.

His superiors backed him to the hilt, however, and cited in his behalf such evidences of accomplishment as the fact that the Allies landed in North Africa virtually without resistance.

In one particular situation, however, Mr. Murphy and his superiors in Washington found themselves at odds.

During the 1948 Berlin crisis, Murphy and Gen. Clay flew here to seek "permission to try to break the blockade." The decision went against them.

Mr. Murphy later recalled that as the one occasion on which he felt he should have resigned in protest.

A man known for delivering his views with a smile but backing them with a will of iron, mr. Murphy later said he "suffered anguish" over the decision "not to challenge the Russians."

In "Diplomat Among Warriors," a 1964 memoir, he expressed deep regret that he was "associated with an action that caused Soviet leaders to downgrade United States determination and capability and led, I believe, to the subsequent Communist provocation in Korea."

Despite those misgivings over the American policy decision, Mr. Murphy carried it out loyally.

He received many awards and decorations, including the National Security Medal, which described him as "a man of legendary achievement in the cause of freedom during World War II."

He is survived by two daughters, Rosemary Murphy and Mrs. Geoffrey Pond, and a grandson. His wife, Mildred, died in 1974.

 

"Un homme dont les liens avec le monde du renseignement remontent à son service dans la légation américaine à Berne, en Suisse, à partir de 1917, 1919, lorsque le maître-espion Allen Dulles y était attaché, M. Murphy a fourni des conseils dans ce domaine des présidents Kennedy, Johnson, Nixon et Ford."

……………………......

"Mr Murphy est né et a grandi dans le Milwaukee et c'est un jeune homme qui est arrivé à Washington. 

Après un an en tant que commis de bureau de poste, M. Murphy, sténographe qualifié, qui a été réformé du service de la Première Guerre mondiale pour un pied écrasé, a obtenu un emploi de commis consulaire à la légation de Berne.

Plus tard, il est revenu ici et a étudié le droit la nuit à l'Université George Washington. En 1920, après avoir obtenu son diplôme et obtenu son admission au barreau, il a refusé un poste dans un cabinet d'avocats et est entré au service consulaire, attiré, dit-il, par "l'attrait de travailler à l'étranger".

in Vilain :

"Charly a écrit un livre où il relate ses souvenirs. Le livre est écrit en anglais mais il existe une traduction française. En faisant une petite recherche sur Internet, vous devriez assez facilement trouver un exemplaire en bon état avec la couverture d'origine. Enfin, pour l'instant car d'ici quelques semaines, les exemplaires disponibles risquent d'être rares."

Son unique livre :

 

Il me fait marrer Bertrand Vilain quand il déclare vouloir à tout prix du neuf...

Parce que, lui, si vous lookez bien le plan de son ouvrage...

Les 4 premiers chapitres sont consacrés à radoter des vieilleries...

- Les fouilles  à Morlaix, starring himself (very important) et sa cloche de journaliste...

- Les personnages de l'affaire : Gariel Saleun, Julien Legrand, Pouliquen, Francis Gherdi, Claude Bal, le juge Hervé...

Et oui, une fois encore : "Faites ce que je vous dis, mais faites pas ce que je fais !" 

Et, comme il n'y a pas assez de personnages français dans l'affaire Seznec...

Pour se rendre intéressant, il file à l'étranger en trouver d'autres...

Restons simple...

Face à ce crime breton qui met en scène deux Bretons pour acheter une propriété en Bretagne.

Liliane Langellier. 

 

Partager cet article
Repost0
Pour être informé des derniers articles, inscrivez vous :
Commenter cet article
A
J'avais bien pensé, moi aussi, en regardant la couverture du livre de B. Vilain, à Robert Murphy, diplomate-barbouze bien connu de quiconque connaît un peu l'histoire de la seconde guerre mondiale (son rôle à Vichy, puis en Algérie).<br /> Mais le document reproduit mentionne "Mr. Murphy, of the State Department".<br /> Certes, les diplomates sont tous rattachés du Département d'Etat (ou au Foreign Office, ou au Quai d'Orsay), Mais l'expression "of the State Department" ferait plutôt penser à un fonctionnaire en poste à Washington qu'à un vice-consul exerçant en Suisse ou en Allemagne. Mais je me trompe peut-être : il se peut que le "State Department" renvoie collectivement à la fois aux diplomates à l'étranger et aux fonctionnaires de l'administration centrale. <br /> B. Vilain dit, de plus, qu'il "a plutôt un nom ayant une consonance française". Or Murphy est incontestablement un patronyme d'origine irlandaise.<br /> Et, s'il est "est inconnu du dossier d'instruction", il ne l'est "peut-être pas du commissaire Vidal.". Comment le "bel Achille" aurait-il pu connaître le vice-consul des Etats-Unis à Munich ?
Répondre